*Inducted in first eligible year
A
B
| Alton Ball, Class of 1935 Football, Basketball, Crew Inducted in 1992 |
James Ballantine, Class of 1955 Baseball, Football Inducted in 1985 |
| Scott Barber, Class of 1990 Baseball Inducted in 2003 |
C. Timothy Barnum, Class of 1975 Cross Country, Track Inducted in 1992 |
| Raymond Beck, Class of 1937 Baseball, Football Inducted in 1993 |
Charles Black, Class of 1979 Football, Track Inducted in 2001 |
| Randolph Blake, Class of 1973 Football, Basketball, Track Inducted in 2000 |
John Bowser, Class of 1937 Football, Basketball, Crew Inducted in 1986 |
| J. Michael Brandts, Class of 1987 Baseball Inducted in 1999 |
Brenda Brdicka, Class of 1987 Basketball Inducted in 1999 |
| Kim Brown, Class of 1989 Basketball, Softball Inducted in 2002 |
Gerald Bumbaugh, Class of 1972 Baseball Inducted in 1995 |
| William Bumham, Class of 1967 Crew Inducted in 1994 |
Jim Burton, Class of 1979 Baseball Inducted in 2005 |
| James Byer, Class of 1966 Crew Inducted in 1996 |
C
| Dan Cawley, Class of 1939 Golf Inducted in 1991 |
Arthur Clark, Class of 1976 Basketball Inducted in 1997 |
| Cathy Clark*, Class of 1990 Basketball Inducted in 2001 |
Doug Cook, Class of 1991 Baseball Inducted in 2006 |
| David Coulter, Class of 1961 Football Inducted in 1997 |
James Cua, Class of 1990 Football Inducted in 2005 |
D
| Mark Davis, Class of 1955 Basketball Inducted in 1984 |
David Drennen, Class of 1955 Football, Basketball Inducted in 1998 |
| Donald Drumm, Class of 1915 Baseball, Football, Basketball Coached: Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1984 |
E
| Bob Eddy, Class of 1994 Baseball Inducted in 2007 |
Arthur Eggenberger, Class of 1928 Baseball, Basketball Inducted in 1999 |
F
| Bradford Fawley, Class of 1977 Cross Country, Track Inducted in 1996 |
Frank Fenton, Class of 1936 Basketball, Crew Inducted in 1989 |
| John Foster, Class of 1974 Crew, Football Inducted in 2005 |
Harold Funke, Class of 1963 Baseball, Football, Track Inducted in 1992 |
G
| Dallas Garber, Class of 1961 Football Inducted in 1984 |
Kelly Gillard, Class of 1991 Basketball, Volleyball Inducted in 2002 |
| Sheldon Gilman, Class of 1908 Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1998 |
Abbey Gladstone, Class of 1978 Baseball, Soccer Inducted in 1993 |
H
| E. Dudley Harris, Class of 1926 Baseball, Football, Basketball, Track Inducted in 1985 |
Traci Hart , Class of 1992 Soccer Inducted in 2006 |
| Brock Hayes, Class of 1951 Baseball Inducted in 1994 |
Frank Hayes, Class of 1919 Football, Basketball Coached: Football, Basketball Inducted in 1984 |
| Terence Heaton, Class of 1964 Football Inducted in 1990 |
Ned Hickel, Class of 1936 Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1985 |
| Karl Hiebel, Class of 1935 Baseball, Football Inducted in 1988 |
Samuel Hirt, Class of 1962 Basketball Inducted in 1987 |
| Jimmy Hissam, Class of 1962 Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1987 |
William Holmes*, Class of 1989 Baseball Inducted in 2000 |
| Henry Hoyt, Class of 1936 Tennis Inducted in 1996 |
Dale Hurst, Class of 1982 Baseball Inducted in 1997 |
I
| Greg Inselmann, Class of 1979 Baseball, Football Inducted in 2001 |
J
| Stephen James*, Class of 1979 Football, Wrestling Inducted in 1990 |
Byron Johnson, Class of 1887 Baseball Inducted in 1984 |
| Douglas Jones, Class of 1972 Football Inducted in 1991 |
James Jordan, Class of 1952 Baseball, Football Inducted in 1987 |
K
| James Katschke, Class of 1986 Baseball Inducted in 1998 |
Arthur "Ozzie" Kenyon, Class of 1973 Baseball Inducted in 2003 |
| Bill Kingzett, Class of 1979 Soccer, Wrestling Inducted in 2006 |
L
| Violet LeClair Coached: Basketball, Field Hockey Inducted in 1997 |
Brian Lee, Class of 1980 Baseball Inducted in 2002 |
| Ralph Lindamood, Class of 1946 Coached: Crew Inducted in 1988 |
Evan Lipp, Class of 1988 Football Inducted in 2000 |
| Kenneth Lisko*, Class of 1982 Baseball Inducted in 1993 |
Matt Littlefield, Class of 1986 Basketball Inducted in 2005 |
M
| Ellis MacDonald Crew Inducted in 1993 |
Roderick MacLeod, Class of 1972 Cross Country, Track & Field Inducted in 2008 |
| Michael Madeja, Class of 1951 Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1990 |
Harley Magee, Class of 1938 Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1994 |
| James Malone, Class of 1986 Soccer Inducted in 2003 |
Joseph Manley Coached: Baseball Inducted in 1985 |
| Jack Marks, Class of 1966 Basketball Inducted in 1991 |
Donald McCool, Class of 1956 Basketball Inducted in 1990 |
| Marvin McCormick, Class of 1958 Baseball, Basketball Inducted in 1986 |
Joe McDaniel Coached: Football Inducted in 1984 |
| Mitchell Miracle, Class of 1979 Basketball Inducted in 1994 |
Thomas Mohl, Class of 1982 Baseball Inducted in 1994 |
| Terrence Morris, Class of 1969 Crew Inducted in 2001 |
Bill Mosca, Class of 1978 Baseball Coached: Baseball, Football Inducted in 2007 |
| Terence Mulholland*, Class of 1985 Baseball Inducted in 1996 |
N
| Gene Nangle, Class of 1957 Football, Basketball, Baseball Inducted in 2002 |
Larry Neely, Class of 1970 Football, Track Inducted in 1989 |
| Arpard Nevada, Class of 1930 Baseball, Football Inducted in 1991 |
Frank Nuckles, Class of 1936 Football, Crew Inducted in 2001 |
| David Nystrom, Class of 1967 Crew Inducted in 2002 |
O
| Jason Olivea, Class of 1996 Football Inducted in 2008 |
P
| James Pancher, Class of 1983 Baseball Inducted in 1998 |
Jim Pheneger , Class of 1962 Baseball, Basketball, Inducted in 2006 |
| Russell Polonus, Class of 1933 Baseball, Football, Basketball, Track Inducted in 1988 |
Q
R
| Fred Rake, Class of 1965 Golf Inducted in 1993 |
Charles Robinson, Class of 1975 Baseball, Basketball Inducted in 1993 |
| Leslye Robinson, Class of 1978 Basketball Inducted in 1997 |
Roland Rutherford, Class of 1949 Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1995 |
S
| Don Schaly*, Class of 1959 Baseball, Football Coached: Baseball, Football Inducted in 2004 |
John Schaly, Class of 1982 Baseball Inducted in 1995 |
| Phil Schmucker, Class of 1986 Football Inducted in 2004 |
Danny Settles, Class of 1976 Baseball, Football Inducted in 1995 |
| Lee Ann Shoemaker*, Class of 1997 Softball, Volleyball Inducted in 2008 |
Kenneth Simmons, Class of 1948 Baseball Inducted in 1995 |
| Dick Sowar, Class of 1966 Basketball Inducted in 2003 |
Jeff Stafford, Class of 1983 Basketball, Track Inducted in 2004 |
| Kim Stanbery, Class of 1975 Baseball Inducted in 1992 |
John Strotbeck III, Class of 1979 Crew Inducted in 1992 |
| Sara Summer, Class of 1989 Soccer, Softball Inducted in 2004 |
Frank Sutton, Class of 1915 Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1984 |
T
| Mark Talarico, Class of 1983 Baseball Inducted in 1996 |
Kenton Tekulve, Class of 1969 Baseball Inducted in 1984 |
| Duane Theiss*, Class of 1976 Baseball Inducted in 1988 |
Dave Thomas, Class of 1984 Baseball Inducted in 2008 |
| Joe Thomas*, Class of 1997 Baseball Inducted in 2008 |
Tina Thomas, Class of 1978 Basketball, Field Hockey Inducted in 2007 |
| Roger Thompson, Class of 1987 Baseball Inducted in 2006 |
James Tracy, Class of 1978 Baseball Inducted in 1991 |
| Jeffrey Turecki, Class of 1965 Baseball, Football Inducted in 2000 |
U
V
| Dale VanVoorhis, Class of 1963 Crew Inducted in 1998 |
Carlos Vazquez, Class of 1980 Baseball Inducted in 2000 |
| Joseph Vogt, Class of 1976 Inducted in 1999 |
W
| Lisa Wagner, Class of 1994 Basketball Inducted in 2005 |
Carl Walker, Class of 1926 Baseball, Football, Basketball, Track Inducted in 1986 |
| Arthur Ward, Class of 1926 Baseball, Football, Track Inducted in 1989 |
Ronald Weekley, Class of 1955 Baseball, Basketball, Crew Inducted in 1988 |
| Curt Weikart*, Class of 1996 Football Inducted in 2007 |
William Whetsell Coached: Basketball, Crew, Cross Country Inducted in 1988 |
| Wilbur White, Class of 1914 Baseball, Football, Basketball, Track Coached: Baseball, Basketball Inducted in 1987 |
Donald Whiting, Class of 1921 Baseball, Football, Basketball Inducted in 1984 |
| James Whiting, Class of 1938 Football, Basketball, Crew Inducted in 1990 |
Drew Witouski, Class of 1988 Baseball Inducted in 2003 |
| Robert Wolfarth, Class of 1965 Baseball, Football Inducted in 1985 |
Carl Wolfe, Class of 1963 Basketball Inducted in 1986 |
| Michael Wright, Class of 1965 Baseball Inducted in 1989 |
Matt Wurtzbacher, Class of 1984 Foottball Inducted in 2006 |
X
Y
| Joe Yazombek, Class of 1976 Baseball Inducted in 2004 |
J. Robert Young, Class of 1951 Basketball Inducted in 2007 |
Z
| Kenneth Zeigler, Class of 1937 Football, Basketball, Crew Inducted in 1987 |
